22 Comments
User's avatar
Steve M's avatar

Thank you for a detailed description of what state propaganda looks like. The words of women used to make men look like women.

The only hearts filled with hate by rule and not exception is found in the gender that blames men for their own failures.

Jack Kammer's avatar

Great, Tom. Nicely dissected.

"The others were being watched because authorities believed they might be susceptible to radicalization."

"Yeah, monitor them, bug them , follow them, harass them, interview their teachers and raise suspicion about them, marginalize them, pursue your confirmation bias about how dangerous they are, especially because they are unhappy with women in many ways, and look for opportunities to detain and lock them up."

OR

"Let's talk with these nine young men and see what we can do to help them. Yes, that's a radical idea because if we really want to know what is going on with them they might actually give voice to some behaviors, attitudes that girls and women harbor and that are endorsed and supported by government, philanthropies and media all over France -- and the rest of Europe, America and the world -- that might really need to be acknowledged and addressed with a caring concern for what social justice looks like for young men even though they're -- you know -- not female."

Andrejus Antoninovas's avatar

Lies, lies and again god damn lies.

Celebrating Masculinity's avatar

Here are eleven articles to closely scrutinise for methodological weaknesses, overt asymmetry, assertion of theory rather than searching for neutral evidence, and the drift from academic analysis into activism, amongst other distortions of academic integrity.

1. Fisher, Benakovic, O’Gorman, Rice, Tierney, Miller-Idriss, Dashtgard & Seidler (2026), “Development and application of the Masculinity Content Classification Framework.” Telematics and Informatics. It operationalises a continuum from ordinary male lifestyle content to harmful manosphere content. Particularly significant is the authors' reflexivity statement: the principal coders disclose left-wing political perspectives and criticism of aspects of online masculinity content. The empirical application nevertheless finds only 5.76% of sampled videos in its two manosphere categories, versus 37.74% classified as “cultural touchpoints.”

2. Meger (2026), "Misogyny, Online Radicalisation, and Youth Extremism in Australia". University of Melbourne. Probably the strongest policy/intervention attempt in this list. It explicitly investigates misogyny as a predictor of extremism and recommends incorporating misogyny and anti-feminism into counter-extremism frameworks and targeting the “manosphere pipeline.” Particularly important is its treatment of anti-feminism as legitimising male grievance and transforming it into political identity.

3. Wescott, Roberts & Zhao (2024), “The problem of anti-feminist ‘manfluencer’ Andrew Tate in Australian schools: women teachers’ experiences of resurgent male supremacy.” Gender and Education, 36(2), 167–182. An especially useful article for examining sampling and theoretical framing: it uses interviews with 30 Australian women teachers and Connell's hegemonic-masculinity framework to interpret boys' behaviour partly as legitimising gender inequality and reinvigorating “male supremacy.”

4. Roberts, Fairchild, Keleher, Trott & Wescott (2025), “‘Adolescence’, manufactured outrage and instructed victimhood: How the discourse on boys’ alienation is fuelled by anti-feminist agendas.” European Journal of Cultural Studies. One of the most important articles for testing how the literature handles male disadvantage itself. It argues that men's-rights groups, commentators, influencers and some men's-health advocates can construct “instructed victimhood” by presenting feminism and gender equality as harmful and re-centring boys as victims. The published author biography also explicitly describes Wescott's “research and advocacy” as including dismantling manosphere influence and advancing gender justice for women and girls.

5. García-Mingo & Díaz Fernández (2023), “Wounded men of feminism: Exploring regimes of male victimhood in the Spanish manosphere.” European Journal of Cultural Studies, 26(6), 897–915. An excellent example of whether male victimisation claims are investigated empirically or primarily interpreted through an ideological/discursive framework. Its starting proposition is that narratives of male victimhood are being used to justify misogynistic claims and support an anti-feminist strategy.

6. Ging (2019; first published 2017), “Alphas, Betas, and Incels: Theorizing the Masculinities of the Manosphere.” Men and Masculinities, 22(4), 638–657. This is a foundational theoretical article in this list. Ging characterises the phenomenon as a “toxic brand of antifeminism” and theorises the different masculinities of the manosphere. Its very high subsequent citation count makes it particularly important for tracing how theoretical assumptions propagate through later research.

7. Aiston (2023), “Digitally Mediated Misogyny and Critical Discourse Studies: Methodological and Ethical Implications.” Modern Languages Open, 2023(1). Possibly the cleanest article for studying researcher positionality. Aiston explicitly reflects on how being a “female, feminist linguist” affects her manosphere research and argues that critical discourse studies can empower researchers to adopt a critical, including feminist, stance toward controversial subjects.

8. Hopton & Langer (2022), “‘Kick the XX out of your life’: An analysis of the manosphere’s discursive constructions of gender on Twitter.” Feminism & Psychology, 32(1), 3–22. Explicitly grounded in feminist research and useful for examining the treatment of male victimhood. Its analysis interprets manosphere discourse through strategies including “co-opting discourses of oppression” and concludes that these discourses cast men as victims while reinstating gendered power hierarchies.

9. Haslop, Ringrose, Cambazoglu & Milne (2024), “Mainstreaming the Manosphere’s Misogyny Through Affective Homosocial Currencies: Exploring How Teen Boys Navigate the Andrew Tate Effect.” Social Media + Society, 10(1). This is a valuable article for the list, because it combines analysis of Tate's videos with a small focus group of 13–14-year-old boys and interprets the material through hegemonic masculinity and misogyny. It therefore provides an excellent comparison with research that instead begins with boys' developmental, psychological or social needs.

10. Franklin-Paddock, Platow & Ryan (2025), “From Privilege to Threat: Unraveling Psychological Pathways to the Manosphere.” Archives of Sexual Behavior, 54, 1325–1340. Examining this article is particularly valuable methodologically, because two correlational studies operationalise men's acknowledgement of male privilege, perceived feminist threat and endorsement of manosphere attitudes. The reported model finds lower acknowledgement of privilege associated with greater perceived feminist threat, which in turn correlates with manosphere attitudes.

11. Baker, Catherine; Ging, Debbie; & Andreasen, Maja Brandt (2024), "Recommending Toxicity: The role of algorithmic recommender functions on YouTube Shorts and TikTok in promoting male supremacist influencers". DCU Anti-Bullying Centre, Dublin City University. Highly relevant to this list. The study creates simulated 16- and 18-year-old male accounts, including “gender-normative” accounts seeking gym, sports and gaming content, and examines whether recommendation algorithms lead them toward manosphere material. The researchers coded content relating to men's rights, anti-feminism and “neo-masculinist influencers.”

Tom Golden's avatar

Now that is a lot of debunking!

DouglasEW's avatar

A good list and even though it is just a tiny segment of the poor excuse for academic study, it's worth keeping.

As for Hopton & Langer (2022), well done for extracting any meaning. It is so full of word-salad psuedo jargon, my brain couldn't cling to anything much from that one!

Fred's avatar

One of your best posts, Tom.

Tom Golden's avatar

Thank you Fred.

James Norris's avatar

Thanks again Tom. Individually feel like Sisyphus in this ongoing battle for the hearts and minds of international community to educate and make aware of the misandrant ideology perpetuated by government and media.

DouglasEW's avatar

Sisyphus never won, never could win, and was all alone.

The MRM, and broader anti-feminist groups, do have wins. Things would be much worse by now otherwise.

You are not alone.

Yvonne Elizabeth  Aston's avatar

We have to be cautious in assigning behavioural characteristics to groups, male, female or undecided. No single person is the same as any other, regardless of sex. One person’s dream may be another’s nightmare. Yes, the security services need to be aware of groups who MAY become radicalised but let’s not assume that they ARE radicalised just by association. My sister is a vegetarian. I am an unrepentant carnivore. Neither she nor I are likely to change our opinions.

DouglasEW's avatar

I don't accept that radical=bad, nor that radical=dangerous. These are concepts that were introduced to pretend that anyone who does not go along with the prevailing mind control must be quashed.

In many parts of the world, and increasingly at the UN, it is radical to believe that children have a right to life, especially where this interferes with their mother's desires.

It is still very radical in many governments to believe that male victims of domestic violence deserve some consideration.

I celebrate radicals. May your radical vegetarian/ carnivore/ herbivore/ omnivore family continue to teach us all about genuine diversity with friendship.

DouglasEW's avatar

"A troubled young man immersed in incel/Black Pill material allegedly planned violence against a particular girl whom he believed had falsely accused his friends of rape."

I've not chased this one down personally but I wonder how true even that statement is, since I have read such fabrications before (though not from France). What proof has been presented that the young man was immersed in any ideology or had any connections with any group? I am inclined to start out thinking:

An allegedly troubled young man allegedly immersed in incel/Black Pill material allegedly planned violence against a particular girl whom he allegedly believed had falsely accused his friends of rape.

That makes blowing it all up into national misandry even further from good truth and starts the entire chain off with guesses.

One wonders what reason he had to allegedly believe his friends had been falsely accused of rape. Is this only the horrifyingly high statistical probability? Or might he have something real to listen to, if anyone really cared what an allegedly troubled young male had to say about the world he lives in?

Concerned Male's avatar

Feminism is not about equality in any way whatsoever!

It is an ideology based on nothing but hatred of men and boys and is really all about POWER and SPECIAL STATUS FOR WOMEN IN ALL THINGS but WITHOUT any RESPONSIBILITY or ACCOUNTABILITY

Phillip Hickox's avatar

Feminisms dark psychology

"the trait you constantly condemn in another person maybe standing there because you own identity refused to claim it, Your stongest judgement may be pointing towards your deepest denial."

David Stanley Lavery's avatar

More double standard misandry and sexism from the hypocrite female gender, being an incel myself, i have no reason to like women, they are cruel and sexist and no one helps men so its no surprise we hate women.

Fred's avatar

I'm sorry for your suffering (and certainly understand it). I hope you are not alone in this. I hope you have found some male support groups.

David Stanley Lavery's avatar

I have Asperger's syndrome so i don't have any friends but women don't want me so i am always alone.

Fred's avatar

How awful! I just googled “Asperger's support groups for adults” and got a lot of leads and organizations. Maybe, there is something for you. I hope so. 🤗

David Stanley Lavery's avatar

I attended a group for people with Asperger's, we also talked on Whats app, but one day i was talking to someone and another women took offence at something i said so there was an argument and all the women in the group started attacking me then i was asked to leave the group. i don't get help frpom anyone now.